Calvinism Analyzed
Calvinism Analyzed
Click the Titles below to expand and collapse the details.
For (Supporting) Calvinism |
Against (Refuting) Calvinism |
---|---|
Acts 13:48 Claim Acts 13:48 does not support Calvinism. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Romans 9 Claim Romans 9 does not support Calvinism. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) John 6:44 Claim John 6:44 does not support Calvinism. For (Supporting) Calvinism John 6:44 proves Calvinism; more specifically, this shows
Romans 9:32 Claim Romans 9:32 proves that faith is not a work. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Romans 4:5 Claim Romans 4:5 proves that faith is not a work. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Jonathan Edwards on the will Claim Edwards (erroneously) conflates desire or "preferring," with will or choosing. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Jonathan Edwards on double predestination Claim Jonathan Edwards argued for double predestination, that God's not electing some is still a choice / decision. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Thomas Jefferson on Calvinism Claim Thomas Jefferson thought Calvinism was wrong. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Will Durant on Calvinism Claim Will Durant did not hold Calvinism in high regard. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Fruit of Calvinism Claim Calvinism encourages ungodliness. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Spurgeon rejected limited atonement Claim Charles Haddon Spurgeon emphatically rejected Limited Atonement. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) John 9:3 Claim John 9:3 does not teach that God causes sickness, nor does it teach that God is glorified by sickness. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Does anyone love me? Claim Calvinism tends toward destruction of feeling loved. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) God is glorified by ordaining everything ?? Claim God is glorified by ordaining all events, since this means God is sovereign. For (Supporting) Calvinism If God did not ordain all events, He would not be sovereign. Making God less than sovereign is lessening God's glory. Limited atonement does not glorify God Claim Limited atonement does not glorify God For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Sovereignty requires micro-manipulation? Claim Sovereignty of God does not require micro-manipulation. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Synergism - monergism & 1 Cor 1:21 Claim Synergism and monergism represent a false dichotomy, not found in scripture. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) Does synergism imply weakness of God? Claim "Synergism" does not imply weakness of God. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) 2 Pet 3:9 Claim 2 Pet 3:9 indicates God's will is that all be saved. For (Supporting) Calvinism TBA (to be added) |
Acts 13:48 Claim: Acts 13:48 does not support Calvinism. Against (Refuting) Calvinism:
John 6:44 Claim: John 6:44 does not support Calvinism. Against (Refuting) Calvinism:
Romans 9:32 Claim: Romans 9:32 proves that faith is not a work. Against (Refuting) Calvinism:
We see in Romans 9:32 that works are not faith. Romans 4:5 Claim: Romans 4:5 proves that faith is not a work. Against (Refuting) Calvinism:
In the above scripture we see that the person who has faith, who believes, is not performing a work. Thus, faith is not a work. Jonathan Edwards on the will Claim: Edwards (erroneously) conflates desire or "preferring," with will or choosing. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: In Edwards' own words: [emphasis added] Jonathan Edwards on double predestination Claim: Jonathan Edwards argued for double predestination, that God's not electing some is still a choice / decision. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: In Edwards' own words: [emphasis added] Thomas Jefferson on Calvinism Claim: Thomas Jefferson thought Calvinism was wrong. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: Thomas Jefferson said in a letter to John Adams (both men were early US presidents) ... Will Durant on Calvinism Claim: Will Durant did not hold Calvinism in high regard. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: Dr. Durant won the Pulitzer prize and the Presidential Medal of Freedom, awarded by US President Gerald Ford. Durant was a historian and philosopher. Durant's book The Story of Philosophy is credited with introducing philosophy to more people than any other book ever written in the world. His multi-thousand page, 11 volume historical work, The Story of Civilization, took 5 decades to write. 1 Below is a quote from Will Durant regarding John Calvin: Fruit of Calvinism Claim: Calvinism encourages ungodliness. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: Calvinism says (erroneously):
The resultant fruit is too often the conclusion:
Spurgeon rejected limited atonement Claim: Charles Haddon Spurgeon emphatically rejected Limited Atonement. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: In Spurgeon's own words:
John 9:3 Claim: John 9:3 does not teach that God causes sickness, nor does it teach that God is glorified by sickness. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: In John 9:3 we read the following, regarding a man born blind:
We must recall that punctuation was not in the original. I put a period in the verse, as in the quote below. I take the verse to mean this:
Does anyone love me? Claim: Calvinism tends toward destruction of feeling loved. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: Calvinism claims (incorrectly, thank God!) most people to be doomed to damnation from birth with no hope. Fortunately, there really is hope! But - and this is where Calvinism gets this totally wrong - not according to Calvinism. This obviously might lead some who believe this to be true, toward despair. For some people who might feel unloved by people, there could be hope that at least God loves them. Calvinism destroys such hope of love. Example: one person upon realizing the implications of Calvinism, cried for 18 hours. God is glorified by ordaining everything ?? Claim: God is glorified by ordaining all events, since this means God is sovereign. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: Ordaining wickedness does not glorify the person who ordained it. It might be argued that, not the wickedness per se, but the ability, or power, to be able to control all events, is the real essence of why those events (even wicked events) glorify the powerful one who ordained them. This reasoning elevates the power of God. Power is one of God's attributes. It is not the only one. Others? Love. Justice. Righteousness. Holiness. Truthfulness. Goodness. Limited atonement does not glorify God Claim: Limited atonement does not glorify God Against (Refuting) Calvinism: Limited atonement does not glorify God, instead it paints the picture of God as a tyrant, unjust, respecter of persons, not a loving God. Is faith a work Claim: Faith is not a work. Against (Refuting) Calvinism:
In the above scripture we see that the person who has faith, who believes, is not performing a work. Thus, faith is not a work. Sovereignty requires micro-manipulation? Claim: Sovereignty of God does not require micro-manipulation. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: TBA (to be added) Synergism - monergism & 1 Cor 1:21 Claim: Synergism and monergism represent a false dichotomy, not found in scripture. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: Synergism claims God is helped by man to do something, in particular, salvation. Monergism claims God does it all - salvation - by himself. Man's free choice to receive Christ as savior, is considered by Calvinism as synergism - man helping God out. However, God does all the saving. God just chose to do all the saving for certain people. Calvinists claim God does choose to (or has chosen to) save only certain people. On the other hand, God himself claims he chose to save certain people also - specifically, those people that believe. Does synergism imply weakness of God? Claim: "Synergism" does not imply weakness of God. Against (Refuting) Calvinism: See also Synergism - Monergism. Calvinism claims that if God wants all to be saved, literally all people, and man can choose to reject salvation, then man is overpowering God. However, by this line of reasoning, Peter was right in trying to forbid man from overpowering God in crucifying the Messiah! But Jesus did not see it this way, in Matt 16:23. 1 But, we might argue, Peter was going against God's plan. 2 Pet 3:9 Claim: 2 Pet 3:9 indicates God's will is that all be saved. Against (Refuting) Calvinism:
|